Soccer Records

Soccer Celebration

YEAR BY YEAR RESULTS

 OVERALL NORTHERN SUN       
YEARW L T PCT WLT GOALSGA G/GMGA/GMCOACH
19954 6 0 .400     1419 1.401.90Paul Stubbs
199610 7 1 .583     3632 2.001.77Paul Stubbs
199716 5 0 .762     10434 4.951.62Paul Stubbs
199812 5 0 .706     6830 3.581.58Paul Stubbs
199916 4 0 .800     6516 3.250.80Seth Brown
20007 9 0 .438     2635 1.622.19Seth Brown
200111 10 0 .524     5533 2.621.57Brock Thompson
200214 6 2 .682     6330 2.861.36Brock Thompson
200314 8 2 .625     6637 2.751.54Brock Thompson
200415 7 2 .667     6323 2.731.00Levi Evans
20058 8 2 .500     3327 1.831.50Levi Evans
20069 9 3 .500 432 (5th)* 2928 1.321.27Levi Evans
200716 7 0 .696 630 (4th)* 3917 1.690.74Levi Evans
200811 10 1 .523 931 (4th) 3628 1.611.25Levi Evans
20099 8 4 .524 742 (5th) 1825 0.811.13Levi Evans
20107 7 5 .500 634 (5th) 2624 1.291.19Levi Evans
201111 8 1 .575 751 (4th) 3525 1.691.20Levi Evans
201210 8 0 .556 1050 (5th) 2924 1.611.33Sarah Cook
20134 10 4 .333 474 (11th) 1937 1.062.06Sarah Cook
20146 8 4 .444 573 (10th) 2228 1.221.56Sarah Cook
20153 12 2 .235 3111 (14th) 2140 1.242.35Sarah Cook
20164 10 3 .324 492 (13th) 2343 1.352.53Sarah Cook
201712 5 2 .684 942 (5th) 3122 1.631.16Sarah Cook
20188 8 3 .500 762 (8th) 2123 1.111.21Sarah Cook
201911 4 3 .694 942 (6th) 3410 1.890.56Sarah Cook
2020-21#2 2 0 .500 --- 98 2.252.00Sarah Cook
20219 7 3 .553 852 (6th) 2518 1.320.95Sarah Cook
202210 5 4 .632 744 (6th) 2312 1.210.63Sarah Cook
202310 8 3 .548 752 (6th) 2318 1.100.86Sarah Cook
202411 4 4 .684 833 (5th) 2612 1.370.63Sarah Cook
20258 7 4 .526 654 (8th) 4020 2.111.05Sarah Cook
* Indicates a Northern Sun Intercollegiate Conference Tournament championship (2006, 2007). 
# Fall 2020 NSIC schedule cancelled due to COVID-19 pandemic 
NCAA Tournament Results
2007  L 1-2 v Central Missouri (NCAA Division II Central Region Tournament at Mankato, MN
NOTE In 2006, the University of Mary began competing in the Northern Sun Intercollegiate Conference and in NCAA Division II. 
Career Head Coaching Records
Coach Years Overall Record Winning Percentage
Paul Stubbs 1995-98 42-23-1      .643
Seth Brown 1999-00 23-13-0 .638
Brock Thompson 2001-03 39-24-4 .611
Levi Evans  2004-11 86-64-18  .565
Sarah Cook 2012-  108-98-39 .520

CAREER RECORDS

Goals Scored
Name GoalsYears
Nicole Benedict662002-05
Sis Merritt431997-00
Rachel Whatmuff411997-00
Tobi Grant 391997-99
Alex Bachman-Williams372010-13
Kate Theisz351996-98
Jazelle Williams312001-04
Jessica Janusz 302005-08
Laura Bartsch301998-01
Megan Wilson 272007-10
Olivia Gardner252022-25
Gina Globa252002-05
Assists Registered
Name AssistsYears
Kate Theisz 371996-98
Sarah McNulty 352001-04
Sis Merritt 311997-00
Jazelle Williams  302001-04
Rachel Whatmuff 281997-00
Gina Globa 272002-05
Jessica Warmack242002-05
Jessica Janusz  222005-08
Tobi Grant 221997-99
Nicole Benedict 212002-05
Points Registered
Name G A Pts Years
Nicole Benedict66 21 153 2002-05
Sis Merritt43 31 117 1997-00
Rachel Whatmuff41 28 110 1997-00
Kate Theisz 35 39 109 1996-98
Tobi Grant39 22 100 1997-99
Jazelle Williams31 30 92 2001-04
Alex Bachman-Williams37 12 86 2010-13
Jessica Janusz 30 22 82 2005-08
Laura Bartsch30 17 77 1998-2001
Gina Globa25 27 77 2002-05
Megan Wilson 27 7 61 2007-10
Olivia Gardner25 7 57 2022-25
Sarah McNulty11 35 57 2001-04
Goals Against Average (Minimum of Seven Games)
Name GAAYears
Molly Fischer0.762021-24  
Carly Feiler 0.821997-00
Madisyn Waltman1.192001-04
Brannigan Coyle 1.212005-08
Rachel Dietrich1.291997-99
Ashley Akers1.322009-12
Kassie Young1.532007-10
Hannah Smith 1.542016-17
Yolanda Davis 1.621999-01
Shelta Arzy1.701995-96
Shutouts
Name  SO  Years
Madisyn Waltman 34 2018-22 
Kristin Werner  25 2001-04
Rachel Dietrich 22 1996-99
Molly Fischer 20 2021-24
Brannigan Coyle 20 2005-08
Carly Feiler 17 2005-09
Yolanda Davis 12 1999-01
Ashley Akers  12 2009-13
Shelta Arzy  10 1999-01

SEASON RECORDS

Goals Scored
Name  Goals Year
Nicole Benedict 272003
Nicole Benedict 242004
Sis Merritt 221997
Kate Theisz 211997
Rachel Whatmuff 171999
Tobi Grant 161997
Tobi Grant 151999
Rachel Whatmuff 151998
Megan Wilson  152007
Assists Registered
Name  AssistsYear
Kate Theisz 191997
Sis Merritt 141998
Jazelle Williams 132003
Sarah McNulty 122001
Tobi Grant 121999
Kate Theisz 121998
Gina Globa 112004
Sarah McNulty 112003
Sarah McNulty 102002
Points Registered
Name GoalsAssistsPointsYear
Kate Theisz2119611997
Nicole Benedict276602003
Nicole Benedict248562004
Sis Merritt229531997
Tobi Grant1521421999
Jazelle Williams176401999
Tobi Grant165371997
Megan Wilson153332007
Jazelle Williams913312003
Alex Bachman-Williams135312011
Jessica Janusz89252008
Goals Against Average (Minimum of Seven Games)
Name GAGAAYear
Molly Fischer100.532024  
Madisyn Waltman100.532019
Carly Feiler40.532007
Rachel Dietrich50.551999
Madisyn Waltman120.642022
Carly Feiler140.732009
Madisyn Waltman150.802021
Brannigan Coyle130.842007
Molly Fischer180.862023
Ashley Akers90.882010
Yolanda Davis100.901999
Kristin Werner180.972004
Kristin Werner160.982002
Carly Feiler 131.012008
Madisyn Waltman201.062018
Hannah Smith221.132017
Brannigan Coyle261.23 2006
Ashley Akers231.232011
Kristin Werner101.232001
Brannigan Coyle231.352005
Shutouts
Name  SO Year
Kristin Werner 11 2004
Molly Fischer 10 2024
Molly Fischer 10 2023
Madisyn Waltman 9 2022
Madisyn Waltman 9 2019
Carly Feiler 9 2009
Kadyn Dilger 8 2025
Madisyn Waltman 8 2021
Madisyn Waltman 8 2018
Brannigan Coyle  8 2007
Kristin Werner 6 2003
Brannigan Coyle  6 2006
Rachel Dietrich 6 1999
Yolanda Davis 6 1999
Rachel Dietrich 6 1998
Hannah Smith 6 2017
Kristin Werner 5 2002
Brannigan Coyle 5 2005
Carly Feiler 5 2007
Ashley Akers 5 2010

ATHLETIC HONORS

NCAA/Adidas NCAA D-II All-American
NameYearTeam
Megan Wilson20073rd
DC2AA All-Central Region Team
NameYearTeam
Allison Lepp20242nd
NSCAA/adidas All-Central Region Team
NameYearTeam
Jessica Janusz20063rd
Megan Wilson20071st
Jessica Janusz20071st
Danielle Mello20071st
Shanda Lester20073rd
Jessica Janusz20081st
Danielle Mello20083rd
Joanna Drennen20083rd
Joanna Drennen20091st
Amy Tanaka20093rd
Megan Hellrung20103rd
Jessica Curl20112nd
Michelle Jones20112nd
Alex Bachman-Williams20112nd
Michelle Jones20122nd
Alex Bachman-Williams20123rd
Daktronics All-Central Region Team
NameYearTeam
Danielle Mello20072nd
Jessica Janusz20082nd
Joanna Drennen20082nd
Joanna Drennen20091st
Jessica Curl20111st
Michelle Jones20112nd
Alex Bachman-Williams20112nd
Alex Bachman-Williams20122nd
United Soccer Coaches All-Central Region
NameYearTeam
Caitlin Dooley20173rd
Megan Lowery20173rd
NSCAA/adidas All-Central Region Team
NameYearTeam
Jessica Janusz20063rd
Danielle Mello2006HM
Shanda Lester2006HM
Megan Wilson20071st
Danielle Mello20071st
Jessica Janusz20072nd
Shanda Lester20072nd
Liz Keller2007HM
Amy Tanaka20082nd
Danielle Mello20082nd
Joanna Drennen20082nd
Carly Feiler2008HM
Joanna Drennen20091st
Amy Tanaka20092nd
Megan Hellrung20093rd
Megan Wilson20093rd
Carly Feiler2009HM
Megan Hellrung20103rd
Amy Tanaka20103rd
Alex Bachman-Williams2010HM
Michelle Jones20111st
Jessica Curl20112nd
Alex Bachman-Williams20112nd
Sami Axtman20113rd
Kelsey Pacpaco20113rd
Dayna Domingo2011HM
Michelle Jones20121st
Alex Bachman-Williams20122nd
Ashley Akers2012HM
Alex Bachman-Williams20132nd
Shelby Buttron2013HM
Michelle McGeary20142nd
Andrea Muller20143rd
Michelle McGeary20153rd
Michelle McGeary20161st
Caitlin Dooley20172nd
Megan Lowery20172nd
Caylin Cathey20173rd
Jade Smith20173rd
Elizabeth Patterson2017HM
Caylin Cathey20182nd
Caitlin Dooley20183rd
Kylee Welch20183rd
Hannah Richter20191st
Kylee Welch20192nd
Malia Brudvik20192nd
Madisyn Waltman20192nd
Cassidy Pierce20193rd
Samantha Guzman2019HM
Kayla Alcott20212nd
Samantha Guzman20212nd
Cassidy Pierce20212nd
Hannah Richter20212nd
Madisyn Waltman20212nd
Mo Malone20222nd
Kendra Park20222nd
Rio Spruenken20222nd
Madisyn Waltman20222nd
Mo Malone20232nd
Eli Olsen20232nd
Olivia Gardner20232nd
Ava Vizenor20232nd
Mo Malone20241st
Allison Lepp20241st
MaLiah Burke20242nd
Olivia Gardner20242nd
Rio Spruenken20242nd
Molly Fischer20242nd
NSIC All-Tournament Team
NameYear
Jessica Janusz2006
Danielle Mello2006
Shanda Lester2006
Beth Gartner2006
Brannigan Coyle2006
Megan Wilson2007
Jessica Janusz2007
Shanda Lester2007
Joanna Drennen2007
Joanna Drennen2008
Megan Lowery2018
Mo Malone2023
Olivia Gardner2023
Eli Olsen2023
Allison Lepp2024
NSIC Tournament MVP
NameYear
Jessica Janusz2006
Megan Wilson2007
NSIC Newcomer of the Year
NameYear
Amy Tanaka2008
NSIC Offensive Player of the Week
NameWeek
Alex Bachman-Williams10.10.11
Alex Bachman-Williams09.17.12
Alex Bachman-Williams10.21.13
Megan Wilson10.09.07
Hannah Richter10.07.19
Olivia Gardner10.30.23
Olivia Gardner10.27.25
NSIC Defensive Player of the Week
NameWeek
Shanda Lester09.18.07
Danielle Mello10.01.07
Joanna Drennen09.01.09
Ashley Akers10.18.10
Ashley Akers11.02.10
Caitlin Dooley09.08.15
Malia Brudvik10.15.18
Kylee Welch09.16.19
Malia Budvik10.21.19
Cassidy Pierce09.27.21
Cassidy Pierce10.04.21
Mary Meeks08.29.22
Eli Olsen09.06.22
Eli Olsen09.19.22
Mo Malone10.23.23
Mo Malone09.23.24
Mo Malone11.11.24
NSIC Goalkeeper of the Week
NameWeek
Shelby Buttron10.21.13
Shelby Buttron11.03.14
Hannah Smith09.05.17
Madisyn Waltman09.27.21
Molly Fischer09.23.24
Kadyn Dilger10.13.25
NSIC Preseason Player of the Year
NameYear
Amy Tanaka (Offensive)2008
Mo Malone (Defensive)2024

ACADEMIC HONORS

NSIC All-Academic Team 2008-12
NameYear
Kirsten Anderson2008
Brannigan Coyle2008
Carly Feiler2008
Megan Hellrung2008
Jessica Janusz2008
Kelsey Kunz2008
Erin Lemay2008
Cassie Meendering2008
Danielle Mello2008
Jill Rounds2008
Amanda Schreiber2008
Megan Wilson2008
Kirsten Anderson2009
Dana Asplund2009
Sami Axtman2009
Sara Callaway2009
Jessica Curl2009
Alyssa Deutscher2009
Carly Feiler2009
Megan Hellrung200
Kelsey Kunz2009
Ashley Akers2010
Sami Axtman2010
Sara Callaway2010
Jessica Curl2010
Chelsea Eades2010
Sara Gillum2010
Megan Hellrung2010
Ashley Tuschling2010
Ashley Akers2011
Samantha Axtman2011
Alex Bachman-Williams2011
Sara Callaway2011
Jessica Curl2011
Sara Gillum2011
Jessie McKenzie2011
Kyna Nakama2011
Kayla Schuh2011
Shantel Schuh2011
Ashley Tuschling2011
Ashley Akers2012
Alex Bachman-Williams2012
Blaire Brookshire2012
Andrea Muller2012
Ashley Tuschling2012
Kaitlin Walsh2012
NSIC All-Academic Team 2013-17
NameYear
Alex Bachman-Williams2013
Barbara Bakh2013
Mykala Benjamin2013
Blaire Brookshire2013
Destiny Glaser2013
Quin Glaser2013
Andrea Muller2013
Mikayla Schutte2013
Jacquelyn Smith2013
Kaitlin Walsh2013
Barbara Bakh2014
Mykala Benjamin2014
Blaire Brookshire2014
Destiny Glaser2014
Michelle McGeary2014
Andrea Muller2014
Alexis Nahring2014
Zara O’Hagan2014
Jacquelyn Smith2014
Mykala Benjamin2015
Katie Berg2015
Kendra Cook2015
Kelsey Ekstedt2015
Destiny Glaser2015
Elizabeth Heintzman2015
Michelle McGeary2015
Alexis Nahring2015
Jacquelyn Smith2015
Katie Berg2016
Kendra Cook2016
Elizabeth Heintzman2016
Emily Julian2016
Michelle McGeary2016
Alexis Nahring2016
Jade Smith2016
Tara Welch2016
Kendra Cook2017
Josefine Dahlberg2017
Patricia Martin2017
Karleen Pappert2017
Taylor Pettigrew2017
Kaelie Schumacher2017
Jade Smith2017
Kylee Welch2017
NSIC All-Academic Team 2018-21
NameYear
Megan Lowery*2018
Patricia Martin*2018
Taylor Pettigrew*2018
Emma Davies*2018
Katie Berg*2018
Kylee Welch2018
Jade Smith2018
Snædís Daníelsdóttir2018
Cassidy Pierce2018
Karleen Pappert2018
Kaelie Schumacher2018
Hannah Richter2018
Malia Brudvik*2019
Snædís Daníelsdóttir2019
Emma Davies*2019
Reegin Kehn*2019
Patricia Martin*2019
Taylor Pettigrew*2019
Cassidy Pierce2019
Kaelie Schumacher2019
Madisyn Waltman*2019
Kylee Welch2019
Emma Davies*2020
Elizabeth Gilbertson*2020
Madisyn Waltman*2020
Abigail Hoff*2020
Reegin Kehn*2020
Noelle Vigneri*2020
Cassidy Pierce*2020
Marriann Senftner*2020
Maureen Sullivan2020
Rachel Neff2020
Yasmina Dokara2020
Snædís Daníelsdóttir2020
Samantha Rosenkranz2020
Emma Davies*2021
Yasmina Dokara2021
Elizabeth Gilbertson*2021
Abigail Hoff*2021
Reegin Kehn*2021
Rachel Neff*2021
Cassidy Pierce*2021
Hannah Richter2021
Marriann Senftner*2021
Emma Snider*2021
Maureen Sullivan*2021
Elizabeth Thompson*2021
Noelle Vigneri*2021
Madisyn Waltman*2021

(* indicates NSIC All-Academic Team of Excellence)

NSIC All-Academic Team 2022-24
NameYear
Elizabeth Gilbertson*2022
Madisyn Waltman*2022
Taylor Meyrick*2022
Marriann Senftner*2022
Kaitlyn Schwass*2022
Yasmina Dokara*2022
Ava Vizenor2022
Jessica Lemmon2022
Mary Meeks2022
Molly Fischer2022
MaLiah Burke*2023
Olivia Gardner*2023
Rio Spruenken*2023
Mo Malone*2023
Brianna Ramey*2023
Olivia Buckle*2023
Kira Hockley*2023
Andi Hunsicker*2023
Isabelle Parson2023
Eli Olsen2023
Ava Vizenor2023
Molly Fischer2023
Mary Meeks2023
MaLiah Burke*2024
Ellie Feeney*2024
Olivia Gardner*2024
Rio Spruenken*2024
Mo Malone*2024
Andi Hunsicker*2024
Kadyn Sharpe*2024
Kira Hockley*2024
Molly Fischer2024
Payton Kooiman2024
Ava Vizenor2024
Tara Young2024
Audrey Garlitz2024
Ashlyn Davison2024
Amelie Faa2024
Isabelle Parson2024
Sophia Lange2024
NSIC Myles Brand All-Academic with Distinction Honor
NameYear
Alex Bachman-Williams2013-14
Michelle McGeary2016-17
Kendra Cook2017-18
Alexa Hutzenbiler2017-18
Megan Lowery2018-19
Patricia Martin2019-20
Taylor Pettigrew2019-20
Emma Davies2020-21
Reegin Kehn2021-22
Emma Snider2021-22
Madisyn Waltman2021-22
Elizabeth Gilbertson2022-23
Taylor Meyrick2022-23
Marriann Senftner2022-23
Mo Malone2024-25
Andi Hunsicker2024-25
NSIC Honor Student-Athlete Award
NameYears
Madisyn Waltman2021, 23
College Sports Communicators Academic All-District 
NameYear
Yasmina Dokara2022
Kaitlyn Schwass2022
Marriann Senftner2022
Ava Vizenor2022
Madisyn Waltman2022
Mo Malone2023
Olivia Gardner2023
Kira Hockley2023
Andi Hunsicker2023
MaLiah Burke2023
Rio Spruenken2023
Mo Malone2024
Molly Fischer2024
Olivia Gardner2024
Kira Hockley2024
MaLiah Burke2024
Rio Spruenken2024

NAIA HONORS

NAIA All-Americans
Name Year Team
Sarah McNulty 2002 3rd
Nicole Benedict 2003 1st
NAIA Honorable Mention All-Americans
NameYear(s)
Tobi Grant1999
Rachel Whatmuff1999, 2000
Janelle Vigil2000
Heidi Hanson2000
Laura Bartsch2001
Natalie Kirchoffner2001
Jazelle Williams2001-04
Nicole Benedict2002, 04
Sarah McNulty2003-04
Kristin Werner2003-04
Shanda Lester2004
NAIA Scholar-Athletes
Name Year(s)
Michelle Bartsch 1996-97
Kate Theisz 1997-98
Starlyn O’Callaghan 1998
Brooke Bertelson 1998-99
Tobianne Grant 1999
Laura Bartsch 2000
Kim Mueller 2002
Nicole Benedict 2004
Jessica Warmack 2004